Rating Alliances

[Dom Zak]

Mostly Harmless Alliance 9
New Pacific Order 9
New Polar Order 7
Sparta 6
Viridian Entente 4
Fark 5
Mushroom Kingdom 6
Orange Defense Network 6
United Purple Nations 6
FOK 6
Global Alliance And Treaty Organization 4
The Legion 8
The Order Of The Paradox 10
Ragnarok 6
RnR 7
The Order Of Light 6
Random Insanity Alliance 4
Umbrella 4
Poison Clan 4
Commonwealth Of Sovereign Nations 5
Nueva Vida 4
Federation Of Armed Nations 8
Independent Republic Of Orange Nations (Not fair, I would be bias even if I tried not to be)
Siberian Tiger Alliance 7
Multicolored Cross-X Alliance 5
The Grand Lodge Of Freemasons 6
Athens 4
Nordreich 3
The International 3
The Foreign Division 4
LOSS 4
Nusantara Elite Warriors 6
The Grämlins 7
Guru Order 5
North Atlantic Defense Coalition 5
M*A*S*H 4
The Templar Knights 4

[Lusitan]

[quote name='LJ Scott' date='18 April 2010 - 11:31 PM' timestamp='1271629900' post='2265411']
You literally tried to merge your alliance into us like 5 days back. Even when that failed, you tried to join us. Which by the way, was going to fail. We just kept your application going as it was a comdey goldmine. For better or worse, we don't get applicants of your calibre very often.

I'll give one rating, which is TFD - 1. Do you guys even have an admission policy?
[/quote]

I'll make it easier for you and just quote Article I of TFD's Charter, the same since our foundation 3 years ago:

[quote]All members of the Foreign Division have to add “The Foreign Division” into their "Alliance Affiliation” and their nation bio. “The Foreign Division” has no team color and is an inter-color alliance, although we prefer the blue team.

Membership in “The Foreign Division” is open to all members of CyberNations. We don’t ask you where you were and what you did. Here with us only what you are and do now and in the future counts. This is your place to start over, leave the past behind and move on. We ask that applicants don't join under false pretenses end any war(s) and diplomatic situations they may be involved in prior to seeking membership.

All members enjoy the right of free speech, security and identity protection. It is illegal for any government body to investigate the past of any member. This information may only be provided by the members themselves.

All members commit themselves to obey the laws of “The Foreign Division” and inform themselves about laws and rules.
[/quote]

As for the rating, I don't think we were brilliant, but I think we did decently both times we fought you.

EDIT: Also, Midoo's rating was silly, specially because he was not a member of TFD during the last war. Furthermore, you were the best adversaries we fought.

Edited April 19, 2010 by Lusitan

[acrux]

[quote name='oOoMidooOo' date='18 April 2010 - 08:06 AM' timestamp='1271577952' post='2264737']
The Rating is out of 10.

Umbrella 2
[/quote]

Haters be hatin.

[AnCapistan]

Just going by alliances I've actually fought in the last war.

Ragnarok - 7.5
ODN - 5.5
GOD - 6.5
MK - 8
CSN - 5
VE - 6
Sparta - 2

The others I have no idea about :shrug:

[wfbone]

Mostly Harmless Alliance 1. good guys terrible fighters

Sparta 2

Fark 9 All of my tough opponents of the war excluding a couple came out of this fierce AA

Mushroom Kingdom 5 i mustve not fought many good MKers because these guys severely disappointed me

Orange Defense Network 5 decent , had some really awesome fighters but in communications the came off as total $@!-wipes

FOK 5 meh

Independent Republic Of Orange Nations 9 i think we did pretty well, what impressed me most about my former clan is how well we coordinated and how long theyre still goin

Athens 4


Yes i know not much, im still pretty young

[Duke Nukem]

Mostly Harmless Alliance 8
New Pacific Order 4
New Polar Order 6
Sparta 2
Viridian Entente 7
Fark 5
Mushroom Kingdom 9
Orange Defense Network 8
United Purple Nations 5
FOK 4
Global Alliance And Treaty Organization 7
The Legion 4
The Order Of The Paradox 6
Ragnarok 3
RnR 8
The Order Of Light 2
Random Insanity Alliance
Umbrella 7
Poison Clan 8
Commonwealth Of Sovereign Nations 9
Nueva Vida 2
Federation Of Armed Nations 1
Independent Republic Of Orange Nations 7
Siberian Tiger Alliance 8
Multicolored Cross-X Alliance 1
The Grand Lodge Of Freemasons 2
Athens 5
Nordreich 2
The International 1
The Foreign Division 5
LOSS 2
Nusantara Elite Warriors 3
The Grämlins 0
Guru Order 4
North Atlantic Defense Coalition 5
M*A*S*H 2
The Templar Knights 5

[Ryan Greenberg]

[color="#48D1CC"]Mostly Harmless Alliance[/color]: 2
[color="#FF0000"]New Pacific Order[/color]: 4
[color="#0000FF"]New Polar Order[/color]: N/A
Sparta: 2
[color="#006400"]Viridian Entente[/color]: 4
[color="#48D1CC"]Fark[/color]: 7
[color="#48D1CC"]Mushroom Kingdom[/color]: 5
[color="#FF8C00"]Orange Defense Network[/color]: 1
[color="#4B0082"]United Purple Nations[/color]: 4
[color="#FF8C00"]FOK[/color]: 4
[color="#A0522D"]Global Alliance And Treaty Organization[/color]: 6
[color="#800080"]The Legion[/color]: 3
[color="#FF8C00"]The Order Of The Paradox[/color]: 1
[color="#48D1CC"]Ragnarok[/color]: 7
[color="#FF8C00"]RnR[/color]: 5
[color="#C0C0C0"]The Order Of Light[/color]: 4
[color="#8B0000"]Random Insanity Alliance[/color]: 3
Umbrella: 5
Poison Clan: 3
[color="#8B0000"]Commonwealth Of Sovereign Nations[/color]: 4
[color="#0000FF"]Nueva Vida[/color]: 5
[color="#FFFF00"]Federation Of Armed Nations[/color]: 5
[color="#FF8C00"]Independent Republic Of Orange Nations[/color]: 2
[color="#C0C0C0"]Siberian Tiger Alliance[/color]: 10
[color="#0000FF"]Multicolored Cross-X Alliance[/color]: 3
The Grand Lodge Of Freemasons: 5
[color="#48D1CC"]Athens[/color]: 1
Nordreich: 4
[color="#FF8C00"]The International[/color]: 5
[color="#0000FF"]The Foreign Division[/color]: 4
LOSS: 3
[color="#C0C0C0"]Nusantara Elite Warriors[/color]: 2
[color="#48D1CC"]The Grämlins[/color]: 2
[color="#48D1CC"]Guru Order[/color]: 3
[color="#0000FF"]North Atlantic Defense Coalition[/color]: 1
[color="#9932CC"]M*A*S*H[/color]: 4
[color="#8B0000"]The Templar Knights[/color]: 4

[Sandwich Controversy]

it's exceedingly obvious a lot of you don't even know what you're rating here

[Gamemaster1]

[quote name='Sandwich Controversy' date='19 April 2010 - 10:38 PM' timestamp='1271731064' post='2267266']
it's exceedingly obvious a lot of you don't even know what you're rating here
[/quote]
Pretty much.

Mostly Harmless Alliance: 2
New Pacific Order: n/a
New Polar Order: n/a
Sparta: 2
Viridian Entente: na
Fark: 7
Mushroom Kingdom: 8
Orange Defense Network: 3
United Purple Nations: n/a
FOK: n/a
Global Alliance And Treaty Organization: n/a
The Legion: n/a
The Order Of The Paradox: n/a
Ragnarok: n/a
RnR: n/a
The Order Of Light: mixed bag of actives and inactives, 5
Random Insanity Alliance: n/a
Umbrella: n/a
Poison Clan: n/a
Commonwealth Of Sovereign Nations: n/a
Nueva Vida: n/a
Federation Of Armed Nations: 2 (6 for their history)
Independent Republic Of Orange Nations: bias
Siberian Tiger Alliance: n/a
Multicolored Cross-X Alliance: n/a
The Grand Lodge Of Freemasons: n/a
Athens: 1 :/
Nordreich: n/a
The International: n/a
The Foreign Division: n/a
LOSS: 8
Nusantara Elite Warriors: n/a
The Grämlins: 0 (I've only fought in the lower ranks though, higher ranks might be better)
Guru Order: n/a
North Atlantic Defense Coalition: n/a
M*A*S*H: n/a
The Templar Knights: n/a

[The AUT]

[quote name='Sandwich Controversy' date='20 April 2010 - 03:38 AM' timestamp='1271731064' post='2267266']
it's exceedingly obvious a lot of you don't even know what you're rating here
[/quote]

2's, 3's and 5's being dropped on Umbrella PC and NEW. I think they're about on par with military performances wouldn't you agree?

[Sandwich Controversy]

Yes, I agree. All of those alliances are terrible

[Voytek]

The only alliances I've fought in recent times have been FOK, \m/, VE and TOP. All my opponents from the first three alliances were terrible (with one exception from VE) and I was really only acting as a speedbump to my TOP foes so.

[Mushroom Man]

[color="#48D1CC"]Mostly Harmless Alliance[/color]: 9
[color="#FF0000"]New Pacific Order[/color]: 10
[color="#0000FF"]New Polar Order[/color]: 7
Sparta: 8
[color="#006400"]Viridian Entente[/color]: 4
[color="#48D1CC"]Fark[/color]: 3
[color="#48D1CC"]Mushroom Kingdom[/color]: 1
[color="#FF8C00"]Orange Defense Network[/color]: 3
[color="#4B0082"]United Purple Nations[/color]: 7
[color="#FF8C00"]FOK[/color]: 3
[color="#A0522D"]Global Alliance And Treaty Organization[/color]: 7
[color="#800080"]The Legion[/color]: 8
[color="#FF8C00"]The Order Of The Paradox[/color]: 9
[color="#48D1CC"]Ragnarok[/color]: 4
[color="#FF8C00"]RnR[/color]: 5
[color="#C0C0C0"]The Order Of Light[/color]: 8
[color="#8B0000"]Random Insanity Alliance[/color]: 4
Umbrella: 2
Poison Clan: 2
[color="#8B0000"]Commonwealth Of Sovereign Nations[/color]: 4
[color="#0000FF"]Nueva Vida[/color]: 5
[color="#FFFF00"]Federation Of Armed Nations[/color]: 5
[color="#FF8C00"]Independent Republic Of Orange Nations[/color]: 8
[color="#C0C0C0"]Siberian Tiger Alliance[/color]: 5
[color="#0000FF"]Multicolored Cross-X Alliance[/color]: 7
The Grand Lodge Of Freemasons: 6
[color="#48D1CC"]Athens[/color]: 3
Nordreich: 4
[color="#FF8C00"]The International[/color]: 4
[color="#0000FF"]The Foreign Division[/color]: 7
LOSS: 6
[color="#C0C0C0"]Nusantara Elite Warriors[/color]: 3
[color="#48D1CC"]The Grämlins[/color]: 2
[color="#48D1CC"]Guru Order[/color]: 6
[color="#0000FF"]North Atlantic Defense Coalition[/color]: 8
[color="#9932CC"]M*A*S*H[/color]: 7
[color="#8B0000"]The Templar Knights[/color]: 4


Some of the other ratings in here amuse me.

Edited April 20, 2010 by Mushroom Man

[AnCapistan]

[quote name='Sandwich Controversy' date='19 April 2010 - 07:38 PM' timestamp='1271731064' post='2267266']
it's exceedingly obvious a lot of you don't even know what you're rating here
[/quote]

I think a lot of people are grading on what they think of the alliances rather then their fighting ability.

[Sandwich Controversy]

That's exactly what I meant, yeah.

Edited April 20, 2010 by Sandwich Controversy

[Banksy]

[quote name='Mushroom Man' date='20 April 2010 - 04:34 PM' timestamp='1271734442' post='2267338']
Some of the other ratings in here amuse me.
[/quote]
I assumed he was joking~

[Yukon Don]

[quote name='Mr Damsky' date='19 April 2010 - 08:35 PM' timestamp='1271734530' post='2267340']
I think a lot of people are grading on what they think of the alliances rather then their fighting ability.
[/quote]

...or many are rating alliances they haven't fought with or against. I didn't read all of them, but I saw Ragnarok as low as 3 and as high as 9, and a number of them were 3s and 4s and the 9 wasn't even a RoK member. I found it amusing to say the least...but clearly at some level its a popular vote. Personally I don't know enough about most of the other nations here to judge them.

I remember your name, and if memory serves me correctly we did some pretty good destruction to each other in one of the wars over the past year. I don't really recall who was the best fighting machine we faced, and mostly because I spend most of my time focusing on the guys in my military unit, not on the alliance as a whole.

I couldn't judge which alliances were the best fighting machines as I don't know most of them, other than occasional diplomatic discussions on IRC or the forums.

[D34th]

[quote name='Sandwich Controversy' date='20 April 2010 - 12:38 AM' timestamp='1271731064' post='2267266']
it's exceedingly obvious a lot of you don't even know what you're rating here
[/quote]

I blame the OP for not being very clear in the thread topic about what they want to be rated, I blame the OP because how can I rate all those alliances when I just fought PC, Kronos and TOP? And I blame the OP because already there is a thread about rating those who we fought in OWF.

[Sandwich Controversy]

[quote name='D34th' date='20 April 2010 - 12:27 AM' timestamp='1271737649' post='2267418']
I blame the OP for not being very clear in the thread topic about what they want to be rated, I blame the OP because how can I rate all those alliances when I just fought PC, Kronos and TOP? And I blame the OP because already there is a thread about rating those who we fought in OWF.
[/quote]
This one came first.

[D34th]

[quote name='Sandwich Controversy' date='20 April 2010 - 02:32 AM' timestamp='1271737936' post='2267419']
This one came first.
[/quote]

Then I blame me for not looking at the time of the topic creation.

[Smacky]

Well this is a complete failure. It just goes to show it's pointless to ask people to rate anything other than how much they like someone/something.

[Alfred von Tirpitz]

I can only comment on people/alliances i have had occasion to engage in battle.

[u][b]NoCB[/b][/u] :

NV had some excellent Fighters, One Magister Agricolarum stands out in my notes from then
[u][b]Karma[/b][/u] :

IRON all the way, Excellent fighting, excellent coordination, sneaky bribing of SDI techs, they had the works. Thanks for my first ever nukes, its addictive.

[u][b]NpO-\m/ :[/b][/u]
Fought for \m/ the NpO guys were good, good coordination, although not perfect, this time it was my turn to bribe the SDI techs in your nations.
[u][b]
TOPGate: [/b][/u]
NEW

[Starfox101]

New Polar Order - 0

Okay, apparently this is rating their war skills? I still give them a 0.

Edited April 20, 2010 by Starfox101

[ironchef]

Mostly Harmless Alliance 8
New Pacific Order 8
New Polar Order 6
Sparta 6
Viridian Entente 8
Fark 6
Mushroom Kingdom 6
Orange Defense Network 4
United Purple Nations ?
FOK 5
Global Alliance And Treaty Organization ?
The Legion 6
The Order Of The Paradox 10
Ragnarok ?
RnR 8
The Order Of Light 6
Random Insanity Alliance 5
Umbrella 5
Poison Clan 5
Commonwealth Of Sovereign Nations ?
Nueva Vida ?
Federation Of Armed Nations 6
Independent Republic Of Orange Nations 10
Siberian Tiger Alliance 8
Multicolored Cross-X Alliance 6
The Grand Lodge Of Freemasons ?
Athens 6
Nordreich ?
The International ?
The Foreign Division 6
LOSS ?
Nusantara Elite Warriors ?
The Grämlins 3
Guru Order ?
North Atlantic Defense Coalition 5
M*A*S*H 5
The Templar Knights 6

[peron]

[quote name='Alfred von Tirpitz' date='20 April 2010 - 02:28 AM' timestamp='1271744895' post='2267586']
NV had some excellent Fighters, One Magister Agricolarum stands out in my notes from then
[u][b]Karma[/b][/u] :

IRON all the way, Excellent fighting, excellent coordination, sneaky bribing of SDI techs, they had the works. Thanks for my first ever nukes, its addictive.

[u][b]NpO-\m/ :[/b][/u]
Fought for \m/ the NpO guys were good, good coordination, although not perfect, this time it was my turn to bribe the SDI techs in your nations.
[u][b]
[/quote]

Who gave you our bribing techniques!!