[quote name='Sardonic' timestamp='1350878002' post='3043986']
Alright, since you asked nicely and without overt malice I'll tell you.
1. EoGing somebody for fighting back because of a raid action diminishes the importance of the EoG list. The EoG list should be reserved for those who have committed unjustified wrongs against us.
2. It is arguable that he didn't, strictly speaking, do anything morally out of line, though he chose the incorrect path in attempting to secure peace for his group by striking at us like a rogue, rather than getting a protectorate from somebody.
3. After conferring with our allies on how they deal with similar situations, we decided that ours was out of line with traditional raiding norms.
Of course, I fully expect CoJ and other irrelevant parties to take credit for this massive victory in defense of the raided, but in truth, the peanut gallery had little to no effect on our process.
[/quote]
"striking at us like a rogue"
cry more, so someone attacked you guys for attacking his alliance. that's not rogue like at all. that's what every alliance member should do if their AA is attacked.