Ok heres the jist of it.
I lost all 5 vessels when battle reports say i lost 4.
I purchased 1 Destroyer, 1 Sub, 3 Aircraft Carriers.
His Attack
My Attack
So if you do the math i should have 1 vessel left.
heres to prove that i bought 5 vessels, i also bought all the level 9 planes up to 75 for the attack.