Jump to content

Awards you want removed  

127 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[center][size="7"]Voting On Awards to be Removed[/size][/center]

this should be pretty self explanatory. Vote for your first, second, and Third choices of Awards to be removed. Sure people can vote for the same award three times, but I don't think that matters that much as it shouldn't drastically affect the outcomes. If one award is voted twice, or even three times, the tie breaker will go to the award with the highest average percentage without being already being removed. Voting will end at 3:00 PM CN time.

Also, it should be important to note that there were 41 awards last year and a limit of 25 options, therefore I had to remove what are my best guesses at the most popular awards. Its not perfect, but its the best I can do. These awards are not included in the above options.

1. Most Powerful Alliance
2. Most Powerful Player
3. Alliance of the Year
4. Player of the Year
5. Best Alliance Leader
6. Best Military
7. Best Rookie Alliance
8. Most Powerful Bloc
9. Best Flag
10. Best DOW
11. Best OWF topic
12. Most Controversial Player
13. Best CN meme
14. Most Active Alliance
15. Most Honorable Alliance
16. Biggest Controversy


[center][size="7"]Nominations for New Categories[/size][/center]

I would like to ask for nominations for new categories. Three new categories will be chosen similary to the three categories we choose to remove. Voting for this will start in two days time.

Current Nominations
Worst Diplomatic error of the year
Best Crazy Person
Most Convincing Player.
most controversial alliance
best rookie player
best war
Worst Diplomatic error of the year

Edited by supercoolyellow
Posted

Remove:
-water cooler thread since that is a terrible forum with no redeeming qualities whatsoever
-game change since there have been [i]literally no game changes[/i] in the last year (unless you count allowing $25 donations :awesome: )
-recruitment staff because this is actually bad for your alliance

Posted

[quote name='Sandwich Controversy' timestamp='1293571229' post='2556481']
Remove:
-water cooler thread since that is a terrible forum with no redeeming qualities whatsoever
-game change since there have been [i]literally no game changes[/i] in the last year (unless you count allowing $25 donations :awesome: )
-recruitment staff because this is actually bad for your alliance
[/quote]

:ph34r: Holy crap, all of those are now winning. SC for most convincing player?

Posted

I voted

Friendliest Alliance
Best Diplomatic Team
Best Economic System

because even their definitions are subjective. An alliance might be really good at its conception of diplomacy or economics, but if they don't agree with what the community thinks is good, then they might not be considered.

Of course you could argue that if they don't agree with the community's conception of what's good, then they're wrong, but that would be disingenuous.

And as a mod, I definitely say less threads are better. :v:

Posted

[quote name='supercoolyellow' timestamp='1293571538' post='2556488']
:ph34r: Holy crap, all of those are now winning. SC for most convincing player?
[/quote]
I support this.

[quote name='kriekfreak' timestamp='1293571663' post='2556495']
Funniest, Best and Nicest Player. Because who cares?
[/quote]
Yeah, these should go too.

Posted

[quote name='Sandwich Controversy' timestamp='1293571229' post='2556481']
-water cooler thread since that is a terrible forum with no redeeming qualities whatsoever
[/quote]
Yeah the same thing repeated over and over again while no one gives a $%&@ about the minuscule government or NS changes, compared to a sub-forum whit actual content bravo.


Oh have a null-vote to.

Posted

[quote name='xoindotnler' timestamp='1293572032' post='2556503']
Yeah the same thing repeated over and over again while no one gives a $%&@ about the minuscule government or NS changes, compared to a sub-forum whit actual content bravo.


Oh have a null-vote to.
[/quote]
Your 4,000 posts in the water cooler betray your bias. If you were to step out and browse other forums on the internet you would see the water cooler for the cesspool it really is.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Sandwich Controversy' timestamp='1293572202' post='2556511']
Your 4,000 posts in the water cooler betray your bias. If you were to step out and browse other forums on the Internet you would see the water cooler for the cesspool it really is.
[/quote]
If you fix the !@#$ hole called Alliance Announcements maybe I will bother visiting it again. Its as interesting as a wet towel and its almost insulting for the towel to say. There is nothing that can been seen as remotely interesting. Its back-rubbers paradise.

If the entire Alliance Announcements section would be removed I wouldn't even notice it, its that interesting and important.

Edited by xoindotnler
Posted

[quote name='kriekfreak' timestamp='1293572027' post='2556502']
Actually I think they should all go. Keep it to those 16 you have in your OP. We don't really need the other categories, do we?
[/quote]

this

I agree, a lot of the awards dont really mean much

Posted

Remove anything that is OOC. The game is about the game and not about what we do personally outside the game.

Also, the alliance/player mostly likely to achieve greatness...shouldn't that be 2011 since we are closing out 2010.

Posted

[quote name='Fernando12' timestamp='1293574396' post='2556547']
Also, the alliance/player mostly likely to achieve greatness...shouldn't that be 2011 since we are closing out 2010.
[/quote]

Yeah, it should be that. Copy/Paste fail. Also more nominations people.

Posted (edited)

Get ride of Friendliest Alliance, Scariest Alliance, and Most Powerful Bloc. The first two are just way too subjective to allow any value to their outcome and the last one is just too stat dependent and not subjective enough.

Edit: added a 't'

Edited by eyriq
Posted

[quote name='Liberated Christian' timestamp='1293577242' post='2556581']
best war.
[/quote]

There were what... 2 wars this year?

Someone isn't doing there job, if that's all we had... :v:

Posted

Is it policy to have no negative awards? I think I remember "Most Hostile Alliance" being up last time (or perhaps it was 2008), but I could be wrong. I don't think "Worst Poster" is a bad idea.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...