Rating alliances

[Essenia]

Also, while some of us find the NSO annoying, it doesn't mean we have any interest in rolling them. I, for one, am perfectly content with letting them live in their own world where they are clearly the single most innovative and cutting edge alliance of all time.

Indeed, we might not ever have known of the concept of 'white peace' had NSO not invented it.

[Corinan]

Indeed, we might not ever have known of the concept of 'white peace' had NSO not invented it.

Did you get our permission before using the term white peace™? You'll be hearing from our attorney.

[Voytek]

I love these kinds of topics.

TOP: 4

MHA: 5

Sparta: 6

NpO: 10

IRON: 5

ODN: 3

FARK: 6

GPA: 3

NPO: 3

FOK: 4

MK: 8

WTF: 5

TOOL: 8

TDO: 4

VE: 4

Legion: 7

RoK: 8

GATO: 5

CSN: 5

Athens: 6

Gremlins: 8

MCXA: 4

UPN: 5

RIA: 5

STA: 9

Invicta: 7

RnR: 5

MASH: 8 ( the flavour)

NADC: 7

WAPA: 5

NV: 8

NSO: 6

NEW: 5

MA: 5

Umbrella: 6

FAN: 5

LoSS: 5

TSO: 1

NATO: 4

Nordreich: 5

GR: 9

Vanguard: 6

GOD

FoB: 5

PC: 3

Valhalla: 6

GGA: 1

TPF: 4

I'm rather conservative with my scoring; a point in either direction away from 5 is worth quite a bit.

Edited November 6, 2009 by Voytek

[Essenia]

Did you get our permission before using the term white peace™? You'll be hearing from our attorney.

Ideas are bulletproof.

[Corinan]

Ideas are bulletproof.

Lawsuits are not, sir.

[Jacques Cousteau]

TOP: 6

MHA: 5

Sparta: 6

NpO: 6

IRON: 4

ODN: 2

FARK: 2

GPA: 7

NPO: 2

FOK: 8

MK: 10

WTF: 1

TOOL: 4

TDO: 1

VE: 8

Legion: 1

RoK: 6

GATO: 7

CSN: 8

Athens: 9

Gremlins: 9

MCXA: 3

UPN: 1

RIA: 3

STA: 8

Invicta: 1

RnR: 8

MASH: 8

NADC: 5

WAPA: 9

NV: 8

NSO: 4

NEW: 4

MA: 8

Umbrella: 9

FAN: 7

LoSS: 5

TSO: 2

NATO: 4

Nordreich: 5

GR: 9

Vanguard: 10

GOD: 8

FoB: 10

PC: 9

Valhalla: 3

GGA: 4

TPF: 1

[Learz]

Eh, might as well. 3 is "meh", 5 is neutral, 7 is "ok". Blanked ones I don't really know. Also, obligatory "this is my opinion and not that of my alliance."

TOP 6

MHA 7

Sparta 5

NpO 5

IRON 5

ODN 3 (Just... oh, I'll keep quiet)

FARK 3

GPA 5 (Too neutral)

NPO 8 (Keep it classy)

FOK 4

MK 5 (MK is.... MK)

WTF (Does anyone really know anything about them? I joined their IRC channel once and there was 1 person in it....)

TOOL

TDO

VE 4 (I still dislike Eph, sorry)

Legion 7

RoK 3

GATO 5 Remembered Easu, so 7

CSN 2

Athens (I won't hold Jack against you, so I'll keep it blank)

Gremlins 9

MCXA 4

UPN 4

RIA 4

STA 9 (Still like you guys)

Invicta

RnR 7 (woulda been a 9 if GFL was still there)

MASH 8

NADC

WAPA 3

NV 5

NSO 6

NEW 4

MA

Umbrella

FAN 8

LoSS

TSO 5

NATO 6

Nordreich 2

GR 8

Vanguard 2

GOD 1 (I doubt much will get me to like you)

FoB

PC 0

Valhalla 5

GGA ...1 Cause if I gave you 0, that would tie PC for last

TPF 5

[Jyrinx]

5 is Neutral, which becomes default if I don't know you.

TOP - 5

MHA - 5

Sparta - 4

NpO - 10

IRON - 4

ODN - 2

FARK - 5

GPA - 5

NPO - 2

FOK - 5

MK - 10

WTF - 5

TOOL - 7

TDO - 5

VE - 4

Legion - 5

RoK - 5

GATO - 5

CSN - 5

Athens - 5

Gremlins - 6

MCXA - 8

UPN - 5

RIA - 5

STA - 10

Invicta - 5

RnR - 5

MASH - 5

NADC - 5

WAPA - 2

NV - 7

NSO - 7

NEW - 5

MA - 5

Umbrella - 8

FAN - 6

LoSS - 5

TSO - 1

NATO - 5

Nordreich - 5

GR - 6

Vanguard - 8

GOD - 5

FoB - 4

PC - 5

Valhalla - 1

GGA - 4

TPF - 3

Edit: Also, as someone said before in about a week or so someone should average out all these ratings.

Edited November 6, 2009 by Jyrinx

[Skippy]

TOP = 3

MHA = 7 --> Crushtania/Scutterbug = win

Sparta = 5

NpO = 10 --> Some really awesome guys there

IRON =

ODN = 6

FARK = 6

GPA = 6

NPO = 4

FOK = 3

MK = 8

WTF = 5

TOOL = 9 --> Mia + Jarkko = win

TDO =

VE =

Legion =

RoK = 5 --> Would be neutral, but Hoo is back

GATO = 6 --> Haven't had too much contact with them, but those I have spoken to are great guys

CSN =

Athens = 8 --> Jgoods wouldn't accept anything lower, oh and those Londo/Rsoxbronco1 guys are alright

Gremlins = 5

MCXA = 6

UPN =

RIA = 5

STA = 10 --> Kind of obvious

Invicta = 5

RnR =

MASH = 5

NADC = 5

WAPA = 2

NV = 8 --> Haven't spoken to many of them, but those I have are great people

NSO = 9 --> As above

NEW = 7 --> K1L10 and Cyrus are old friends

MA =

Umbrella =

FAN = 7 --> I've got a lot of respect for FAN

LoSS = 5

TSO = 1

NATO =

Nordreich =

GR = 7

Vanguard = 7

GOD = 3

FoB =

PC = 1

Valhalla = 2

GGA = 3

TPF = 6 --> Hanging in the war longer than expected, plus I know a lot of them from my Zenith days

Those I have no opinion on are blank.

Updated, probably used the "5" rank a lot better now that those I have no opinion on are blank.

Edited November 6, 2009 by Skippy

[Coven]

Eh, nvm.. Don't feel like posting this.

Edited November 6, 2009 by Airikr

[William Blake]

TOP- 5

MHA- 3

Sparta- 3

NpO- 10

IRON- 8

ODN- 2

FARK- 3

GPA- 5

NPO- 5

FOK- 5

MK- 2

WTF - 5

TOOL - 8

TDO - 5

VE - 3

Legion - 5

RoK - 5

GATO - 5

CSN - 4

Athens - 1

Gremlins - 5

MCXA - 5

UPN - 5

RIA - 1

STA - 6.25

Invicta - 5

RnR - 5

MASH - 5

NADC - 5

WAPA - 5

NV - 5

NSO - 6

NEW - 8

MA - 1

Umbrella - 3

FAN - 5

LoSS - 3

TSO - 2

NATO - 5

Nordreich - 5

GR - 5

Vanguard - 4

GOD - 1

FoB - 1

PC - 2

Valhalla - 6

GGA - 3

TPF - 6

edit: thanks penkala

Edited November 6, 2009 by William Blake

[Penkala]

RIA - 1 Bring it.

You're the ones who claim to be bold and daring, willing to ignore norms and not at all afraid to sacrifice your nation to do what you feel is right, not us. You bring it. Unless you're really just like all other alliances and do care about your precious infrastructure too much to do anything about it.

[bzelger]

Mine:

TOP - 7. A couple of posters that rub me the wrong way, mostly because of how they interact with my allies, but overall intelligent and decent people in my book.

MHA - 5. No real interaction

Sparta - 6. They seem to deal with their issues in a quiet and efficient way once they've found them.

NpO - 10. Terrific allies. Sportsmanlike, intelligent, and honest.

IRON - 5. They have a clean slate post-karma in my book, and I haven't seen anything yet to make me form a new opinion.

ODN - 6. Arsenal has zest. From my superficial, far-removed place I think they've moved past what most people hold against them.

FARK - 6.

GPA - 5. No opinion

NPO - 2. Willfully obtuse.

FOK - 3.

MK - 8. Staunch allies, active community.

WTF - 5. No opinion.

TOOL - 9. A great bunch of people.

TDO - 5. No opinion.

VE - 5. Some good, some bad. More or less balances.

Legion - 3.

RoK - 5. No opinion.

GATO - 7. Points residual for resolve in GATO - 1V war. Haven't seen much since.

CSN - 6. See above. I am a fan of Lord Brendan's posting though.

Athens - 4. Meh

Gremlins - 9. Great posters and people. A shame that we have personality clashes.

MCXA - 5. Rotten history, but I'm willing to see if they can improve.

UPN - 5. No opinion.

RIA - 6. Delta is a good poster.

STA - 10 obviously.

Invicta - 1. lol

RnR - 5. No opinion.

MASH - 5. No opinion.

NADC - 5. No opinion.

WAPA - 5. No opinion.

NV - 8. Hizzy always makes me laugh.

NSO - 8. I don't agree with everything they do (or perhaps rather, how they do it), but they're good allies and fought for us when they didn't have to (Molon Labe is no tech raid either). They have spine but will listen to their allies.

NEW - 1.

MA - 5. No opinion.

Umbrella - 8. A great group. -2 for having government that thinks I'm a sheep.

FAN - 7. No real opinion, +2 for resiliance.

LoSS - 5. No opinion.

TSO - 1.

NATO -3.

Nordreich - 5. No opinion.

GR - 6.

GOD - 1.

FoB - 5. No opinion.

PC - 2.

Valhalla - 3. Kryievla and Bud are good people.

GGA - 4. They superficially appear to have stabilized and have paid handsomely for being a historically lousy alliance. I'd like to see them right their ship and go on to good things.

TPF - 5. Could go either way for me at this point.

I have a spreadsheet with all the ratings in it. I'll put some data up when we get some more ratings.

Edit: http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=tgG...amp;output=html

Based on data inputted so far, I get these bloc averages:

Frostbite 6.5

Citadel 6.2

CnG 6.1

Superfriends 5.5

CDT 4.3

Of course, some of these blocs aren't fully represented, and small representation (FB and CDT) means more skewing for those blocs.

Edited November 6, 2009 by bzelger

[Seipher Caim]

Here ya go! I assure you my results are *TOTALLY* objective smile.gif

...

Valhalla 2

....

Come on Keve !

Explain me why "2"... I take it that all the interactions you had with Valhalla was when I helped you with Graphics at the time of your DoE... So why the hate ? Why following the hate train ?

I understand a lot of the ratings are subjective, but sometimes I really see no ground for them... and it disappoints me.

[Kryievla]

TOP - 7

MHA - 7

Sparta - 9

NpO - 5

IRON - 3

ODN - 7

FARK - 6

GPA - 4

NPO - 1

FOK - 7

MK - 10

WTF - 3

TOOL - 2

TDO - 2

VE - 6

Legion - 2

RoK - 6

GATO - 7

CSN - 5

Athens - 10

Gremlins - 8

MCXA - 2

UPN - 2

RIA - 6

STA - 8

Invicta - 2

RnR - 6

MASH - 7

NADC - 2

WAPA - 4

NV - 6

NSO - 4

NEW - 6

MA - 2

Umbrella - 7

FAN - 7

LoSS - 2

TSO - 2

NATO - 2

Nordreich - 3

GR - 9

Vanguard - 9

GOD - 7

FoB - 9

PC - 9

Valhalla - 2

GGA - 5

TPF - 2

Why would you say '2' for us? As far as I know, we haven't had a lot of interaction except for in the positives, so I was kind of curious on that. Also, I would love to see your thoughts on all the ratings, if you are so inclined.

edit: heh, seipher <3 We need to join the Valhallan lonely hearts club. Where is our love?

Edited November 6, 2009 by Kryievla

[Lord Brendan]

Mine:

FARK - 6.

RoK - 5. No opinion.

CSN - 6. See above. I am a fan of Lord Brendan's posting though.

RIA - 6. Delta is a good poster.

RnR - 5. No opinion.

MA - 5. No opinion.

GOD - 1.

Of course, no bloc (other than FB) is fully represented, and small representation (FB and CDT) means more skewing for those blocs.

So who's the eighth SuperFriend? I must have missed an announcement.

[bzelger]

So who's the eighth SuperFriend? I must have missed an announcement.

Hush, you.

[wickedj]

Mine:

TOP - 7. A couple of posters that rub me the wrong way, mostly because of how they interact with my allies, but overall intelligent and decent people in my book.

MHA - 5. No real interaction

Sparta - 6. They seem to deal with their issues in a quiet and efficient way once they've found them.

NpO - 10. Terrific allies. Sportsmanlike, intelligent, and honest.

IRON - 5. They have a clean slate post-karma in my book, and I haven't seen anything yet to make me form a new opinion.

ODN - 6. Arsenal has zest. From my superficial, far-removed place I think they've moved past what most people hold against them.

FARK - 6.

GPA - 5. No opinion

NPO - 2. Willfully obtuse.

FOK - 3.

MK - 8. Staunch allies, active community.

WTF - 5. No opinion.

TOOL - 9. A great bunch of people.

TDO - 5. No opinion.

VE - 5. Some good, some bad. More or less balances.

Legion - 3.

RoK - 5. No opinion.

GATO - 7. Points residual for resolve in GATO - 1V war. Haven't seen much since.

CSN - 6. See above. I am a fan of Lord Brendan's posting though.

Athens - 4. Meh

Gremlins - 9. Great posters and people. A shame that we have personality clashes.

MCXA - 5. Rotten history, but I'm willing to see if they can improve.

UPN - 5. No opinion.

RIA - 6. Delta is a good poster.

STA - 10 obviously.

Invicta - 1. lol

RnR - 5. No opinion.

MASH - 5. No opinion.

NADC - 5. No opinion.

WAPA - 5. No opinion.

NV - 8. Hizzy always makes me laugh.

NSO - 8. I don't agree with everything they do (or perhaps rather, how they do it), but they're good allies and fought for us when they didn't have to (Molon Labe is no tech raid either). They have spine but will listen to their allies.

NEW - 1.

MA - 5. No opinion.

Umbrella - 8. A great group. -2 for having government that thinks I'm a sheep.

FAN - 7. No real opinion, +2 for resiliance.

LoSS - 5. No opinion.

TSO - 1.

NATO -3.

Nordreich - 5. No opinion.

GR - 6.

GOD - 1.

FoB - 5. No opinion.

PC - 2.

Valhalla - 3. Kryievla and Bud are good people.

GGA - 4. They superficially appear to have stabilized and have paid handsomely for being a historically lousy alliance. I'd like to see them right their ship and go on to good things.

TPF - 5. Could go either way for me at this point.

Based on data inputted so far, I get these bloc averages:

Frostbite 6.5

Citadel 6.2

CnG 6.1

Superfriends 5.5

CDT 4.3

Of course, some of these blocs aren't fully represented, and small representation (FB and CDT) means more skewing for those blocs.

how high does SF jump if you remove CSN lol

Hows this for our new recruitment message: Join CSN, we're the most average alliance around

[bzelger]

how high does SF jump if you remove CSN lol

Hows this for our new recruitment message: Join CSN, we're the most average alliance around

It doesn't change if I round the same way. Without rounding it jumps from 5.467142857 to 5.533333333.

[Xavii]

TOP - 10 Our oldest and most trusted friends. B)

MHA - 8 Cool alliance, cool allies!

Sparta - 10 Our brother from another mother. Black power!

NpO - 7 Bounced back from a curbstom to grow into a nuclear powerhouse. Respect!

IRON - 6 Have little personal experience with them, but they dealed serious damage in the karma war.

ODN - 5

FARK - 9 Farkilicious, fig1a!

GPA - 5 Keep doing what your doing I guess.

NPO - 3 It would have been a 1 before.

FOK - 9 In dutch I trust!

MK - 10 artpad!

WTF - 5

TOOL - 5

TDO - 5

VE - 7 I like them.

Legion - 5

RoK - 6 Friends of friends.

GATO - 5

CSN - 5

Athens - 7 Got some cool people.

Gremlins - 10 Loves me my Gremlins.

MCXA - 5

UPN - 5

RIA - 8 Cool guys with cool leadership.

STA - 7 Got a few cool people that hang out over in Kevins bedroom.

Invicta - 2 Very annoying during Karma war.

RnR - 7 Cool bunch of people I like!

MASH - 5

NADC - 5

WAPA - 4

NV - 4

NSO - 1 My balls have yet to drop I guess.

NEW - 5

MA - 6 Friends of friends

Umbrella - 10 Obviously

FAN - 5 Yet to see

LoSS - 5

TSO - 7 Friends of friends and getting to know ever more.

NATO - 5

Nordreich - 1 I'm from Norway.

GR - 5

Vanguard - 7 Cool easy going alliance.

GOD - 10 Big_Z

FoB - 7 Yarr!

PC - 9 Trusty allies and now black buddies.

Valhalla - 5 Gave us a nice fight, no whining.

GGA - 1 Its GGA

TPF - 1 I was in Genmay.

Thats about it.

edit : 5's are generally from little personal contact.

Edited November 6, 2009 by Xavii

[Benjamin Arouet]

how high does SF jump if you remove CSN lol

Hows this for our new recruitment message: Join CSN, we're the most average alliance around

That has always been our recruitment message, you just weren't special enough to get the usual one.

[JBone]

10-8 True quality top to bottom.

7-5 Great potential, headed in the right direction.

4 Never enters my mind.

3-1 Waste of space.

0 Die in a fire.

TOP - 3

MHA - 4

Sparta - 2

NpO - 8

IRON - 8

ODN - 4

FARK - 3

GPA - 4

NPO - 7

FOK - 3

MK - 8

WTF - 4

TOOL - 7

TDO - 4

VE - 5

Legion - 5

RoK - 6

GATO - 7

CSN - 4

Athens - 0

Gremlins - 2

MCXA - 6

UPN - 4

RIA - 4

STA - 8

Invicta- 5

RnR - 4

MASH - 4

NADC - 4

WAPA - 4

NV - 6

NSO - 7

NEW - 9

MA - 4

Umbrella - 4

FAN - 7

LoSS - 0

TSO - 4

NATO - 4

Nordreich - 7

GR - 3

Vanguard - 2

GOD - 0

FoB - 3

PC - 6

Valhalla - 8

GGA - 1

TPF - 7

[anenu]

10-8 True quality top to bottom.

7-5 Great potential, headed in the right direction.

4 Never enters my mind.

3-1 Waste of space.

0 Die in a fire.

TOP - 3

MHA - 4

Sparta - 2

NpO - 8

IRON - 8

ODN - 4

FARK - 3

GPA - 4

NPO - 7

FOK - 3

MK - 8

WTF - 4

TOOL - 7

TDO - 4

VE - 5

Legion - 5

RoK - 6

GATO - 7

CSN - 4

Athens - 0

Gremlins - 2

MCXA - 6

UPN - 4

RIA - 4

STA - 8

Invicta- 5

RnR - 4

MASH - 4

NADC - 4

WAPA - 4

NV - 6

NSO - 7

NEW - 9

MA - 4

Umbrella - 4

FAN - 7

LoSS - 0

TSO - 4

NATO - 4

Nordreich - 7

GR - 3

Vanguard - 2

GOD - 0

FoB - 3

PC - 6

Valhalla - 8

GGA - 1

TPF - 7

Can it be a nuclear fire? Please please let it be a nuclear fire.

[JBone]

Can it be a nuclear fire? Please please let it be a nuclear fire.

Pull my strings.

http://www.cybernations.net/nation_drill_d...ation_ID=106695

[Ivan Moldavi]

Indeed, we might not ever have known of the concept of 'white peace' had NSO not invented it.

What was your AA back then? Just wondering.

Anyway, if every one liked us then I would feel like a failure. I will never pander to those that oppose us and never go out of my way to be nice just for the sake of getting in someone else's good graces. Cowards can have it.