Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Azaghul

Rating alliances

Recommended Posts

This question in various forms often pops in Q&As MK has with other alliances, and I thought it would be interesting to see what kind of responses it garnered here.

I'm including all the top 40 alliances plus other well known ones. Rate what you think of all these alliances on a 1-10 scale, 10 is really awesome and 1 is really terrible (OOC: IC dislike, you don't have to hate the players /OOC).

TOP

MHA

Sparta

NpO

IRON

ODN

FARK

GPA

NPO

FOK

MK

WTF

TOOL

TDO

VE

Legion

RoK

GATO

CSN

Athens

Gremlins

MCXA

UPN

RIA

STA

Invicta

RnR

MASH

NADC

WAPA

NV

NSO

NEW

MA

Umbrella

FAN

LoSS

TSO

NATO

Nordreich

GR

Vanguard

GOD

FoB

PC

Valhalla

GGA

TPF

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm including all the top 40 alliances plus other well known ones. Rate what you think of all these alliances on a 1-10 scale, 10 is really awesome and 1 is really terrible (OOC: IC dislike, you don't have to hate the players /OOC).

Interesting, please make data out of this after a few days/week.

TOP 7

MHA 5

Sparta 5

NpO 6

IRON 4

ODN 2

FARK 4

GPA 1

NPO 3

FOK 4

MK 8

WTF #

TOOL 3

TDO 1

VE 2

Legion 2

RoK 4

GATO 3

CSN 1

Athens 6

Gremlins 8

MCXA 1

UPN 1

RIA 3

STA 5

Invicta 3

RnR 4

MASH #

NADC 3

WAPA 2

NV 2

NSO 6

NEW 2

MA 2

Umbrella 8

FAN 5

LoSS 2

TSO 5

NATO 3

Nordreich 2

GR 3

Vanguard 4

GOD 5

FoB 5

PC 6

Valhalla 5

GGA 1

TPF 0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP 8

MHA 4

Sparta 5

NpO 6

IRON 5

ODN 1

FARK 7

GPA 1

NPO 5

FOK 7

MK 6

WTF 4

TOOL 2

TDO 1

VE 7

Legion 5

RoK 4

GATO 2

CSN 2

Athens 4

Gremlins 7

MCXA 1

UPN 1

RIA 3

STA 5

Invicta 3

RnR 4

MASH #

NADC 3

WAPA 2

NV 2

NSO 4

NEW 2

MA 2

Umbrella 6

FAN 5

LoSS 2

TSO 5

NATO 3

Nordreich 2

GR 1

Vanguard 4

GOD 5

FoB ?

PC 3

Valhalla 7

GGA 5

TPF 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This should be interesting. If I have never heard of the alliance or never communicated with them in any way I gave them a 5. Building an alliance is hard work so anyone in the top 40-50 deserves some recognition, in my opinion, even if they are tools.

TOP 6

MHA 6

Sparta 3

NpO 10

IRON 7

ODN 6

FARK 5

GPA 4

NPO 8

FOK 5

MK 7

WTF 5

TOOL 5

TDO 5

VE 7

Legion 3

RoK 5

GATO 8

CSN 5

Athens 4

Gremlins 6

MCXA 5

UPN 5

RIA 4

STA 10

Invicta 7

RnR 6

MASH 5

NADC 5

WAPA 5

NV 5

NSO 1001

NEW 5

MA 5

Umbrella 5

FAN 8

LoSS 6

TSO 2

NATO 5

Nordreich 6

GR 5

Vanguard 5

GOD 5

FoB 5

PC 1

Valhalla 5

GGA 5

TPF 7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting. I'm going to give 5's to those alliances who I haven't had an opportunity to render a real judgment on.

TOP - 5

MHA - 8

Sparta - 5

NpO - 8

IRON - 7

ODN - 6

FARK - 6

GPA - 4

NPO - 6

FOK - 7

MK - 9

WTF - 4

TOOL - 4

TDO - 4

VE - 7

Legion - 5

RoK - 7

GATO - 6

CSN - 5

Athens - 8

Gremlins - 8

MCXA - 6

UPN - 5

RIA - 7

STA - 8

Invicta - 6

RnR - 5

MASH - 5

NADC - 5

WAPA - 5

NV - 8

NSO - 4

NEW - 5

MA - 5

Umbrella - 7

FAN - 7

LoSS - 6

TSO - 2

NATO - 5

Nordreich - 4

GR - 9

Vanguard - 9

GOD - 6

FoB - 6

PC - 4

Valhalla - 4

GGA - 5

TPF - 3

The lack of a TMF option upsets me greatly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I take it that "5" would be a neutral score then. :P

TOP 6

MHA 3

Sparta 6

NpO 10

IRON 9

ODN 3

FARK 5

GPA 5

NPO 4

FOK 7

MK 4

WTF 1

TOOL (not going to vote for my own alliance as that really isn't fair)

TDO 2

VE 3

Legion 4

RoK 7

GATO 8

CSN 5

Athens 3

Gremlins 6

MCXA 5

UPN 5

RIA 5

STA 9

Invicta 6

RnR 5

MASH 5

NADC 4

WAPA 8 (WAPA YA BASS!)

NV 8

NSO 5

NEW 10

MA 5

Umbrella 4

FAN 6

LoSS 5 (Elishia is a 10 though :wub: )

TSO 1

NATO 4

Nordreich 5

GR 10

Vanguard 9

GOD 5

FoB 6

PC 2

Valhalla 5

GGA 3

TPF 10

(CCC 11 :lol1: )

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP 7

MHA 7

Sparta 2

NpO 7

IRON 6

ODN 4

FARK 4

GPA 5

NPO 5

FOK 6

MK 8

WTF 3

TOOL 5

TDO 1

VE 4

Legion 3

RoK 4

GATO 6

CSN 2

Athens 4

Gremlins 9

MCXA 4

UPN 1

RIA 4

STA 4

Invicta 8

RnR 3

MASH 3

NADC 2

WAPA 4

NV 5

NSO 5

NEW ?

MA 1

Umbrella 6

FAN 5

LoSS 4

TSO 1

NATO 1

Nordreich 1

GR 6

Vanguard 4

GOD 7

FoB 5

PC 3

Valhalla 5

GGA 3

TPF 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A lot of my rankings are fickle and based on an imperfect knowledge, but hey, the narrative as I understand it leads to me rank them as so. Just for fun!

TOP: 8

MHA: 7

Sparta: 5

NpO: 8

IRON: 5

ODN: 3

FARK: 8

GPA: 5

NPO: 8

FOK: 6

MK: 8

WTF: 2

TOOL: 7

TDO: 2

VE: 4

Legion: 4

RoK: 7

GATO: 6

CSN: 5

Athens: 7

Gremlins: 10

MCXA: 5

UPN: 5

RIA: 4

STA: 6

Invicta: 6

RnR: 5

MASH: 4

NADC: 4

WAPA: 4

NV: 4

NSO: 7

NEW: 5

MA: 5

Umbrella: 9

FAN: 9

LoSS: 5

TSO: 5

NATO: 5

Nordreich: 6

GR: 5

Vanguard: 8

GOD: 4

FoB: 4

PC: 8

Valhalla: 5

GGA: 6

TPF: 6

Average: 5.708333333

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here ya go! I assure you my results are *TOTALLY* objective :)

Good idea btw!

TOP 1

MHA 6

Sparta 3

NpO 10

IRON 2

ODN 3

FARK 8

GPA 2

NPO 2

FOK 5

MK 7

WTF 3

TOOL 4

TDO 2

VE 9

Legion 5

RoK 9

GATO 6

CSN 3

Athens 4

Gremlins 1

MCXA 4

UPN 3

RIA 6

STA 9

Invicta 3

RnR 5

MASH 2

NADC 4

WAPA 6

NV 7

NSO 9

NEW 5

MA 5

Umbrella 1

FAN 8

LoSS 5

TSO 5

NATO 4

Nordreich 8

GR 7

Vanguard 5

GOD 6

FoB 5

PC 6

Valhalla 2

GGA 2

TPF 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My own reply:

TOP- 6 Generally cool people and very competent at nation building.

MHA- 6 Some cool people, but they don't really do a lot, and don't seem very organized.

Sparta- 5 Good allies to Athens and some cool people, but pretty mediocre in terms of ability, they'd get destroyed in a real war.

NpO- 8 :nuke:

IRON- 3 Meh, lame history as #2

ODN- 7 Generally cool people and I believe they are better than their past

FARK- 5 Aqua and fought well, otherwise meh

GPA- 5 Neutrality is boring but otherwise they're pretty cool

NPO- 2 They have a sense of purpose unlike a lot of other alliances, seem pretty active, and that's why I don't give them a 1, but otherwise I dislike almost everything about them.

FOK- 9 Cool people, cool propaganda, very competent, and I really like the way they think.

MK- 10 I wonder why. :wub:

WTF- 4 meh

TOOL- 3 meh

TDO - 4 meh

VE - 5 They're OK

Legion- 3 stockholm syndrome

RoK- 6 I like everything about them but Hoo, their dedication in Karma was impressive.

GATO- 4 meh

CSN- don't know enough to say.

Athens- 9 Dedicated friends

Gremlins- 8 Great people, their internal drama and losses recently make me sad. :(

MCXA- 4 meh

UPN- 3 lol purple

RIA- 5 Delta is cool, otherwise meh

STA- 8 very dedicated

Invicta- 2 lol purple

RnR- don't know enough to say

MASH- don't know enough to say

NADC- 4 meh

WAPA- 5 alright

NV- 8 I like them a lot

NSO - 4 Some cool people and I like that they try to shake things up, but they have a lot of annoying members

NEW - 6 Don't know them well but they seem pretty competent.

MA- 4 meh

Umbrella- 8 cool people, and great allies

FAN- 6 Aren't around as much as they should be

LoSS- don't know enough to say

TSO- 2 the way they left MCXA was pretty horrendous, otherwise meh

NATO- 4 meh

Nordreich- 4 meh

GR- 8 Great people but relatively inactive recently :(

Vanguard- 8 Great alliance

GOD- 5 alright

FoB- 8 Watching them grow has been fun

PC- 5 alright

Valhalla- 5 Respect them as rivals

GGA- 3 meh, pitiable mostly

TPF- 2, they'd be a 4 or 5 if they could get off their cross already.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP 3

MHA 3

Sparta 1

NpO 10

IRON 8

ODN 4

FARK 5

GPA 2

NPO 9

FOK 3

MK 7

WTF 4

TOOL 5

TDO 2

VE 4

Legion 4

RoK 4

GATO 7

CSN 5

Athens 4

Gremlins 6

MCXA 3

UPN 5

RIA 3

STA 8

Invicta 7

RnR 5

MASH 3

NADC 3

WAPA 3

NV 3

NSO 10

NEW 3

MA 3

Umbrella 3

FAN 7

LoSS 1

TSO 1

NATO 6

Nordreich 5

GR 7

Vanguard 5

GOD 1

FoB 4

PC 2

Valhalla 6

GGA 4

TPF 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP- 10

MHA- 6

Sparta- 3

NpO- 5

IRON- 8

ODN- 5

FARK- 7

GPA- 5

NPO- 2

FOK- 6

MK- 2

WTF - 6

TOOL - 6

TDO - 3

VE - 4

Legion - 5

RoK - 7

GATO - 6

CSN - 6

Athens - 3

Gremlins - 8

MCXA - 5

UPN - 5

RIA - 8

STA - 7

Invicta - 4

RnR - 7

MASH - 4

NADC - 5

WAPA - 6

NV - 6

NSO - 2

NEW - 5

MA - 6

Umbrella - 9

FAN - 8

LoSS - 7

TSO - 9

NATO - 5

Nordreich - 3

GR - 5

Vanguard - 5

GOD - 5

FoB - 5

PC - 5

Valhalla - 5

GGA - 2

TPF - 3

Avg: 7.4 (I'm too kind)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This question in various forms often pops in Q&As MK has with other alliances, and I thought it would be interesting to see what kind of responses it garnered here.

I'm including all the top 40 alliances plus other well known ones. Rate what you think of all these alliances on a 1-10 scale, 10 is really awesome and 1 is really terrible (OOC: IC dislike, you don't have to hate the players /OOC).

TOP

MHA

Sparta

NpO

IRON

ODN

FARK

GPA

NPO

FOK

MK

WTF

TOOL

TDO

VE

Legion

RoK

GATO

CSN

Athens

Gremlins

MCXA

UPN

RIA

STA

Invicta

RnR

MASH

NADC

WAPA

NV

NSO

NEW

MA

Umbrella

FAN

LoSS

TSO

NATO

Nordreich

GR

Vanguard

GOD

FoB

PC

Valhalla

GGA

TPF

Darn TTK missed the list by 1 :(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP 4

MHA 3

Sparta 2

NpO 10

IRON 5

ODN 6

FARK 7

GPA 1

NPO 5

FOK 6

MK 9

WTF 3

TOOL 7

TDO 2

VE 3

Legion 7

RoK 8

GATO 5

CSN 5

Athens 5

Gremlins 8

MCXA 4

UPN 7

RIA 2

STA 10000

Invicta 5

RnR 4

MASH 3

NADC 2

WAPA 5

NV 9

NSO 9

NEW 6

MA 4

Umbrella 6

FAN 7

LoSS 2

TSO 0

NATO 2

Nordreich 5

GR 9

Vanguard 7

GOD 2

FoB 6

PC 4

Valhalla 7

GGA 1

TPF 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP 1

MHA 5

Sparta 3

NpO 10

IRON 5

ODN 6

FARK 5

GPA 3

NPO 6

FOK 4

MK 10

WTF 5

TOOL 5

TDO 3

VE 5

Legion 5

RoK 6

GATO 4

CSN 5

Athens 6

Gremlins 7

MCXA 5

UPN 6

RIA 4

STA 10

Invicta 7

RnR 4

MASH 5

NADC 3

WAPA 2

NV 9

NSO 8

NEW 3

MA 5

Umbrella 7

FAN 6

LoSS 6

TSO 0

NATO 4

Nordreich 6

GR 8

Vanguard 6

GOD 5

FoB 6

PC 2

Valhalla 4

GGA 1

TPF 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP 10

MHA 10

Sparta 7

NpO 5

IRON 10

ODN 6

FARK 8

GPA 10

NPO 4

FOK 8

MK 7

WTF 8

TOOL 6

TDO 6

VE 7

Legion 7

RoK 3

GATO 6

CSN 5

Athens 5

Gremlins 10

MCXA 8

UPN 5

RIA 5

STA 5

Invicta 5

RnR 8

MASH 5

NADC 5

WAPA 10

NV 5

NSO 1

NEW 5

MA 5

Umbrella 8

FAN 8

LoSS 5

TSO 9

NATO 5

Nordreich 1

GR 5

Vanguard 5

GOD 5

FoB 5

PC 5

Valhalla 5

GGA 5

TPF 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP 8

MHA 6

Sparta :awesome:

NpO 9

IRON 6

ODN 6

FARK 8

GPA 5

NPO 6

FOK 7

MK 7

WTF 5

TOOL 5

TDO 3

VE 6

Legion 6

RoK 6

GATO 6

CSN 5

Athens 7

Gremlins 9

MCXA 5

UPN 4

RIA 7

STA 6

Invicta 5

RnR 6

MASH 5

NADC 4

WAPA 5

NV 5

NSO 3

NEW 6

MA 4

Umbrella 8

FAN 7

LoSS 4

TSO 4

NATO 5

Nordreich 6

GR 6

Vanguard 5

GOD 6

FoB 7

PC 6

Valhalla 5

GGA 3

TPF 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP 3

MHA 4

Sparta 5

NpO 10

IRON 4

ODN 6

FARK 7

GPA 5

NPO 3

FOK 5

MK 10

WTF 5

TOOL 6

TDO 5

VE 7

Legion 4

RoK 8

GATO 7

CSN 6

Athens 7

Gremlins 6

MCXA 6

UPN 8

RIA 6

STA 10

Invicta 1

RnR 6

MASH 6

NADC 4

WAPA 5

NV 9

NSO 10

NEW 4

MA 6

Umbrella 5

FAN 8

LoSS 2

TSO 0

NATO 6

Nordreich 4

GR 8

Vanguard 7

GOD 6

FoB 6

PC 3

Valhalla 4

GGA 2

TPF 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOP - 5

MHA - 7

Sparta - 8

NpO - 8

IRON -6

ODN - 9

FARK - 10

GPA -3

NPO - 3

FOK - 8

MK - 1

WTF - 5

TOOL - 5

TDO - 5

VE - 5

Legion - 9

RoK - 10!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GATO - 8

CSN -10

Athens - 7

Gremlins -5

MCXA - 5

UPN - 5

RIA - 5

STA - 5

Invicta - 8

RnR - 10

MASH - 5

NADC - 5

WAPA - 5

NV - 7

NSO - 1

NEW - 5

MA - 10!!!!!!!!!

Umbrella - 5

FAN = 8

LoSS - 5

TSO - 5

NATO - 5

Nordreich - 5

GR -5

Vanguard - 8

GOD - 10

FoB - 5

PC - 8

Valhalla - 8

GGA - 5

TPF - 1

5 means i don't know the alliance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I take my hat off to you, as this required me to actually think. Imagine that, thinking in Cybernations. What a novel idea!

Oh, I also voted based on my preference of them, not if they are good at the game or not. Obviously if they are in the top 40, something must have gone right for them.

TOP 3

MHA 4

Sparta 5

NpO 6

IRON 3

ODN 3

FARK 3

GPA 2

NPO 1

FOK 3

MK 4

WTF 5

TOOL 2

TDO 3

VE 5

Legion 3

RoK 3

GATO 6

CSN 3

Athens 4

Gremlins 3

MCXA 2

UPN 2

RIA 6

STA 5

Invicta 5

RnR 6

MASH 3

NADC 3

WAPA 3

NV 4

NSO 2

NEW 2

MA 2

Umbrella 5

FAN 4

LoSS 7

TSO 3

NATO 3

Nordreich 4

GR 5

Vanguard 2

GOD 3

FoB 3

PC 2

Valhalla 1

GGA 1

TPF 1

Darn TTK missed the list by 1 :(

TTK 10 for not being in the top 40 :wub:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

MK - 10

Sounds about right :awesome:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Put a 5 if I don't really know them (of course, I also rated some 5s because I have an average opinion of them).

TOP 2

MHA 6

Sparta 6

NpO 4

IRON 5

ODN 7

FARK 9

GPA 6

NPO 5

FOK 8

MK 8

WTF 7

TOOL 7

TDO 6

VE 6

Legion 4

RoK 7

GATO 8

CSN 10

Athens 8

Gremlins 9

MCXA 6

UPN 3

RIA 10

STA 8

Invicta 2

RnR 7

MASH 5

NADC 5

WAPA 5

NV 5

NSO 4

NEW 5

MA 7

Umbrella 7

FAN 7

LoSS 6

TSO 1

NATO 3

Nordreich 5

GR 7

Vanguard 7

GOD 6

FoB 5

PC 5

Valhalla 4

GGA 4

TPF 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×