II. On Reparations
The Grämlins shall not pay reparations for defensive wars and shall not demand reparations for offensive wars.
Yet here you are demanding reparations for offensive wars.
III. On Peace Terms
Peace terms shall not be used to humilate the opponent or to cripple him economically beyond the need to remove the current and immediate threat to the alliance. No terms shall be offered which The Grämlins would not consider acceptable if the sides were switched. The terms shall reflect the opponents' behavior during battle.
Yet here you are humiliating an opponent and offering terms that you would not consider acceptable if the sides were switched.
V. On Treaty Chaining
No mutual defense agreement shall chain with other agreements not signed by The Grämlins.
If you want to make the argument for II that you are in a defensive war, then it is because you chained treaties.
IX. On Grudges
Nations or alliances which have fulfilled their peace terms are considered guilt-free from that moment on and past actions shall not be held against them in future relations.
This is the most important one. You seem to be carrying out a grudge beyond the peace terms from the Karma War.
You are free to do whatever you want in this game, it just makes me sad to see this. When I started playing this game and watching how you handled yourselves and your performance in Karma, this is quite a departure to say the least.