Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: BNP in recent news...
Cyber Nations Forums > Cyber Nations Community Structure > The Water Cooler > The Boiler Room
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Foggers
Okay, I use the word "interesting" quite loosely.

I know we have a few discussions on them but I thought we could have another.

Firstly, they are due to appear on Question Time on the BBC.
The story is here. A few people are not too pleased about this as they think it gives the BNP credility of being a real political party with a real chance. While it will certainly give them publicity, I doubt it will all be good publicity (as in I am sure some people will agree with the views of Nick Griffin).
QUOTE
British National Party leader Nick Griffin will be allowed to appear on Question Time, the BBC Trust has said.

The BBC's governing body had convened a meeting to consider complaints from Welsh Secretary Peter Hain and others about Mr Griffin's appearance.

The trust said it was "a question of editorial judgment" whether it was appropriate for the BNP to appear.

But Mr Hain insisted the BBC had "made one of the biggest mistakes in its proud history".

In an article for Thursday's Guardian newspaper, BBC director general Mark Thompson has said the case against inviting the BNP to appear on Question Time is "a case for censorship".


Also earlier in the week, Nick Griffin compared the British Army generals to the Nazis who were charged at Nuremburg for war crimes.
Article from The Daily Telegraph is here.

QUOTE
Nick Griffin, the BNP leader, accused General Sir Richard Dannatt and General Sir Mike Jackson, two former chiefs of the general staff, of complicity in “illegal” wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and in the MPs’ expenses scandal.

Mr Griffin’s attack came after the generals added their names to a new campaign against the BNP's attempts to “steal the valour” of the Armed Forces by using wartime images and slogans.

I am disgusted and surprised at this. Firstly, the BNP attempting to take the moral high ground. Secondly, I thought Nuremburg was to do with war crimes and human rights abuse, not about a war being illegal.

Also there is this:
QUOTE
Mr Griffin said: “Sir Richard said nothing about the fact that low-paid British soldiers have to buy their own kit because the Government has deliberately underfunded the army, despite sending our soldiers to foreign conflicts which have nothing to do with us.”

Even though heads of all three services have spoken out about the lack of pay, equipment and resources. It is in fact the politicians who should be blamed really.

Anyway, this goes to show the BNP as... not the best as usual? But I am curious as to what other people's views are on the matter.
Conan the Barbeque
You're missing another of the recent BNP's recent events, where they have been slapped with a court order to not discriminate on people joining their party by race (whites only was their policy, now they must change it or be heavily fined).
Alarik Martens
Lets go Nick! This should get us enough donations and attention to keep us going for years to come.
Ethan Smith
Or if he $%&@s up the BNP will be revealed as the ridiculous racialist organization that it is.
Alarik Martens
QUOTE (Ethan Smith @ Oct 21 2009, 05:59 PM) *
Or if he $%&@s up the BNP will be revealed as the ridiculous racialist organization that it is.

Ridiculous and racialist dont' belong in the same sentence. Regardless, he's a pro - he'll do just fine.

Go Nick! Go BNP!
Vaal Satori
QUOTE (Alarik Martens @ Oct 21 2009, 08:01 PM) *
Ridiculous and racialist dont' belong in the same sentence. Regardless, he's a pro - he'll do just fine.

Go Nick! Go BNP!


Racialism is a sign of immaturity. I was a racialist when I was like 8 years old. At some point most people grow up and learn that the world is more complex than 18th century pseudoscience and "us vs them" mentalities.
Alarik Martens
QUOTE (Vaal Satori @ Oct 21 2009, 06:10 PM) *
Racialism is a sign of immaturity. I was a racialist when I was like 8 years old. At some point most people grow up and learn that the world is more complex than 18th century pseudoscience and "us vs them" mentalities.

Complexity belongs to my private life. Simplicity belongs to the broad governence of the people. My philosophy is, the broader the scope - the more general the logic. In other words, the more people we encompass in the topic of choice, the more stereotypical and categorizing we must be.

That's just my opinion though - the least you can do is let the British people make up their own.
Kenadian_2006
QUOTE (Vaal Satori @ Oct 21 2009, 08:10 PM) *
Racialism is a sign of immaturity. I was a racialist when I was like 8 years old. At some point most people grow up and learn that the world is more complex than 18th century pseudoscience and "us vs them" mentalities.


What is a racialist? Is that some mangling of racist?
Alarik Martens
QUOTE (Kenadian_2006 @ Oct 21 2009, 06:18 PM) *
What is a racialist? Is that some mangling of racist?

It's a person who views things of a larger context in a racial mindset without the necessary negative connotation that comes with the term "racist".
Vaal Satori
QUOTE (Kenadian_2006 @ Oct 21 2009, 08:18 PM) *
What is a racialist? Is that some mangling of racist?


In many ways the two terms are synonymous. The only real differences are on an abstruse level, with a racialist ascribing different attributes to different races without judging them, and a racist drawing conclusions based on that about the superiority of one over the other.

In reality though many racists hide behind racialism because it isn't quite as stigmatized by society.
Ethan Smith
QUOTE (Kenadian_2006 @ Oct 22 2009, 12:18 AM) *
What is a racialist? Is that some mangling of racist?


It's a word for racially motivated, or based upon race. Generally racialist policies are racist policies. Huntingtons analysis is, for instance, racialist, because it supposes that, for instance, because most of Latin America has been at some time dictatorships, Latinos don't like democracy. The BNP is similar, in that it supposes that people who have spent their whole lives in Britain, who have been taught in British schools and only speak English, aren't British because of their ethnicity.
Ethan Smith
QUOTE (Alarik Martens @ Oct 22 2009, 12:15 AM) *
Complexity belongs to my private life. Simplicity belongs to the broad governence of the people. My philosophy is, the broader the scope - the more general the logic. In other words, the more people we encompass in the topic of choice, the more stereotypical and categorizing we must be.

That's just my opinion though - the least you can do is let the British people make up their own.


Really?

So you're saying that all things on a macro level have simple solutions.
Alarik Martens
QUOTE (Ethan Smith @ Oct 21 2009, 06:31 PM) *
Really?

So you're saying that all things on a macro level have simple solutions.

Of course not. We're speaking once more of exceptions. Governence of entire countries, however, cannot be based upon exceptions - it must be based upon definitions and I'd dare say even stereotypes.

The irony of asking me if I believe governing by generalization has its exceptions in success is quite delicious though, I must say. tongue.gif
Ethan Smith
QUOTE (Alarik Martens @ Oct 22 2009, 12:35 AM) *
Of course not. We're speaking once more of exceptions. Governence of entire countries, however, cannot be based upon exceptions - it must be based upon definitions and I'd dare say even stereotypes.

The irony of asking me if I believe governing by generalization has its exceptions in success is quite delicious though, I must say. tongue.gif


Then, if the government can't have exceptions, then why make exceptions in the law for different ethnicities?
Mack Truck
The BBC is public owned still, right? If so then they should have interviews with any parties that poll at all. Better than just having the same bland crap from the usual parties.
Kenadian_2006
QUOTE (Ethan Smith @ Oct 21 2009, 08:30 PM) *
It's a word for racially motivated, or based upon race. Generally racialist policies are racist policies. Huntingtons analysis is, for instance, racialist, because it supposes that, for instance, because most of Latin America has been at some time dictatorships, Latinos don't like democracy. The BNP is similar, in that it supposes that people who have spent their whole lives in Britain, who have been taught in British schools and only speak English, aren't British because of their ethnicity.


Ah, spanks to you and Vaal for the explanations.
New Inca Empire
I was thinking Alarik Martens was arguing with himself for a moment there. happy.gif
edikroma
What the hell is going on with this impersonation thing? Did I miss a memo? Hell, even New Inca Empire changed his avatar...
Audeamus
QUOTE (edikroma @ Oct 21 2009, 09:16 PM) *
What the hell is going on with this impersonation thing? Did I miss a memo? Hell, even New Inca Empire changed his avatar...


A strange and wondrous event known to a chosen few as "Halloween".
edikroma
QUOTE (Audeamus @ Oct 21 2009, 10:29 PM) *
A strange and wondrous event known to a chosen few as "Halloween".


We've already started?! I suppose it's just about a week away, isn't it?!
Delta1212
QUOTE (edikroma @ Oct 21 2009, 11:49 PM) *
We've already started?! I suppose it's just about a week away, isn't it?!

That would be correct.
Gustave5436
QUOTE (Alarik Martens @ Oct 21 2009, 05:24 PM) *
It's a person who views things of a larger context in a racial mindset without the necessary negative connotation that comes with the term "racist".


Given that, from an empirical standpoint, there is no such thing as race, and given that, from a sociological standpoint, the belief in race always leads to harm (case in point: Rwandan genocide), any term will have negative connotations, whether it is spelt "racist" or "racialist."

QUOTE (edikroma @ Oct 21 2009, 08:16 PM) *
What the hell is going on with this impersonation thing? Did I miss a memo? Hell, even New Inca Empire changed his avatar...


I hate these dress-up parties. sad.gif

QUOTE (Mack Truck @ Oct 21 2009, 06:48 PM) *
The BBC is public owned still, right? If so then they should have interviews with any parties that poll at all. Better than just having the same bland crap from the usual parties.


I eagerly await the pirate party interviews.
Germanic Republic
QUOTE (Gustave5436 @ Oct 21 2009, 11:46 PM) *
I hate these dress-up parties. sad.gif


Me too sad.gif
Cataduanes
QUOTE (Alarik Martens @ Oct 22 2009, 01:01 AM) *
Regardless, he's a pro - he'll do just fine.

Go Nick! Go BNP!

lol1.gif

A pro you say, does that tag of professionalism also apply to the BNP as a whole in your view? the same BNP that has been wholly incompetent in the various areas of England in which it has managed to get a foothold in local councils? the same BNP that lacks a coherent platform to the real issues facing the United Kingdom such as the economy, public services and the military commitments overseas? whose only concrete issue seems to be race, race, race?.

I for one look forward to Mr Griffin appearing on Question Time, nothing will show the BNP's incompetence on real issues than allowing their leader to have his time on national television, and i strongly disagree with the many commentators citing that the BNP should not be allowed any airtime.

indeed 'Go Nick!', do your stuff biggrin.gif
Foggers
In another BNP discussion a while ago, someone showed a website showing how inept the BNP are.
popsumpot
Actually, if we took the same rules that the Nazi's were prosecuted under in Nuremberg and applied it to everyone, every major Western government would be hanged.
Cataduanes
QUOTE (Foggers @ Oct 22 2009, 11:08 AM) *
In another BNP discussion a while ago, someone showed a website showing how inept the BNP are.


Well one does not have to dig deep to unearth info on BNP's performance in council chambers, here is some info on some of the ''quality'' BNP members in council chambers up and down the country,

QUOTE
(Info dated from 8th April, 2008)

Burnley:

The BNP’s position deteriorated even further when another of its councillors, Luke Smith, smashed a bottle into the face of a fellow BNP supporter. In the resulting by-election the BNP vote halved and the party slipped down into third place.

Blackburn:
The BNP did have one councillor in Blackburn, Robin Evans, but last September he walked out of the party. He then wrote a letter to his former BNP colleagues denouncing Blackburn BNP as a party of drug dealers and football hooligans … Last year Searchlight reported that Evans could not follow council business. “This is all mumbo jumbo,” he told fellow councillors. “I don’t understand a word of it.” The mumbo-jumbo he was referring to was the council budget!

Sandwell:
Last summer Sandwell’s two BNP councillors thought they would outfox their political rivals by proposing a motion to the full council calling on the government to stop sending asylum seekers to the borough.. They knew full well that the motion would fall but they would then be able to tell electors that the BNP was the only party that opposed the arrival of more asylum seekers in the area.

To their surprise the motion was passed with an amendment. The BNP happily supported the new motion quite unaware that the changes reversed everything the BNP originally wanted. So the BNP councillors voted for a motion that sympathised with the plight of asylum seekers, condemned the government for being too harsh on them, attacked the press and politicians who tried to whip up racism and called on the council to accept their responsibility to take more.

Stoke:
Steve Batkin, the BNP’s Stoke councillor, has also failed to impress. During his election campaign last year he questioned the Holocaust and claimed that Jewish people only made an issue of it to make money. His performance has not improved since then. He missed a few meetings early on but now just sits in silence. After eight months in post he had to ask council officials to explain what abstaining meant.

Earlier this year it emerged that he had not paid his council tax since becoming a councillor. He claimed this was because of the long queues of asylum seekers at the council tax office but of course this was nonsense because that office has nothing to do with asylum seekers. However, while he dodged his tax, he did find time to claim his full councillor’s allowance of £100 a week.


Yeah some real quality councillors the BNP has there! no doubt white Middle England (who form the bulk of the national electorate...not the poor white working class who are the core support for the BNP in some areas and who have been increasingly marginalised in both numbers and power since Thatcher's 'reforms' in the 80's) will be running to [sarcasm] vote BNP on account of their obvious 'professionalism' and 'ability' [/sarcasm] laugh.gif
Vladimir
Some more questions about their performance here.
Cataduanes
QUOTE (Vladimir @ Oct 22 2009, 12:34 PM) *
Some more questions about their performance here.

Careful there Vlad least Alarik cites that old BNP argument about all the criticism being nothing more than a Marxist conspiracy biggrin.gif
Kenadian_2006
QUOTE (Gustave5436 @ Oct 22 2009, 12:46 AM) *
Given that, from an empirical standpoint, there is no such thing as race, and given that, from a sociological standpoint, the belief in race always leads to harm (case in point: Rwandan genocide), any term will have negative connotations, whether it is spelt "racist" or "racialist."



I hate these dress-up parties. sad.gif



I eagerly await the pirate party interviews.


Holy crap, Gustave used a smiley.

Also, does anyone have a video link of the question period? Has it even happened yet?
Cataduanes
QUOTE (Kenadian_2006 @ Oct 22 2009, 04:02 PM) *
Also, does anyone have a video link of the question period? Has it even happened yet?

It is due to go on air tonight (UK time), no doubt one of us UK based people will provide a link for all to see.
Kenadian_2006
QUOTE (Cataduanes @ Oct 22 2009, 11:04 AM) *
It is due to go on air tonight (UK time), no doubt one of us UK based people will provide a link for all to see.


So, evening for me then. Yay 5 hour time difference!
Vladimir
It's on tonight at 22:35pm GMT. You might be able to get it on the BBC iplayer an hour or so after it finishes (not sure if there are national restrictions): http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/
Cataduanes
Yeah Vlad has provided the correct link, and it should be a good show biggrin.gif
Kenadian_2006
Thanks for the link Vlad. Hell, I might even be able to catch it on TV. Would BBC World News have it on? Also, yay for it being on at 5 for me.
Ethan Smith
Kenadian you live on the East Coast, right?

So yeah, it'd be on at 5. Sweet.
Kenadian_2006
QUOTE (Ethan Smith @ Oct 22 2009, 11:16 AM) *
Kenadian you live on the East Coast, right?

So yeah, it'd be on at 5. Sweet.


Technically, I live in Central Canada. emot-v.gif
Ethan Smith
QUOTE (Kenadian_2006 @ Oct 22 2009, 03:18 PM) *
Technically, I live in Central Canada. emot-v.gif


So you're not on Eastern time?

So I'm going to have to run out of class to watch this?
Cataduanes
Well if you cannot watch it ''live'' you can catch it on BBC Iplayer within 7 days (?, i think it stays on for a week) of its broadcast.
Kenadian_2006
QUOTE (Ethan Smith @ Oct 22 2009, 11:22 AM) *
So you're not on Eastern time?

So I'm going to have to run out of class to watch this?


Heh, I should clarify. Eastern Canada is the Atlantic Provinces, even if those buggers out West call everything east of Manitoba eastern. Central Canada is Quebec and Ontario. So yes, I am on Eastern Time.

Let's put it another way, I can't live on the Eastern Seaboard for one specific reason. The coast is a good many hundreds of kilometres away. emot-v.gif
Lamuella
no thread about Nick Griffin is complete without this charming photograph of him:

Iosif Moldov
QUOTE (Lamuella @ Oct 22 2009, 06:47 PM) *
no thread about Nick Griffin is complete without this charming photograph of him:



Yeah, Griffin's a racist et cetera et cetera; it's pretty much public knowledge. The sad thing here is that this point appeals to only those who already have negative feelings towards the BNP whereas the most BNP advocates don't deny their own racialism - heck, even the party does not. Thus I tend to think posts like this do not forward the constructivity of this discussion; instead, it just makes sure we get even more BNP morons (i.e. Alarik Martens) with their bizarre view of the world ranting about how cool it actually is to hate the blacks.

Only in Britain!
king of cochin
cata, i dont think the BBC site posted here works for any viewer outside UK. We can only get radio and no TV.
Cataduanes
QUOTE (Iosif Moldov @ Oct 22 2009, 04:53 PM) *
Yeah, Griffin's a racist et cetera et cetera; it's pretty much public knowledge. The sad thing here is that this point appeals to only those who already have negative feelings towards the BNP whereas the most BNP advocates don't deny their own racialism - heck, even the party does not. Thus I tend to think posts like this do not forward the constructivity of this discussion; instead, it just makes sure we get even more BNP morons (i.e. Alarik Martens) with their bizarre view of the world ranting about how cool it actually is to hate the blacks.

Only in Britain!

Hence my posts pointing out the BNP's utter incompetence, i may not like the Extreme Right wing but i do respect the fact that people are allowed to choose what they believe in (democracy is a wonderful thing) and in that sense i do not begrudge BNP supporters. If the BNP could actually show some ability at a local level and provide some credible policies on national issues then perhaps they would gain more than a handful of council seats and MEP roles....alas the BNP has shown themselves to be seriously lacking in either ability or knowledge.

QUOTE (king of cochin @ Oct 22 2009, 05:01 PM) *
cata, i dont think the BBC site posted here works for any viewer outside UK. We can only get radio and no TV.

hmmm i did not realize that, have no fear however no doubt it will be on You tube biggrin.gif
Lamuella
QUOTE (Iosif Moldov @ Oct 22 2009, 11:53 AM) *
Yeah, Griffin's a racist et cetera et cetera; it's pretty much public knowledge. The sad thing here is that this point appeals to only those who already have negative feelings towards the BNP whereas the most BNP advocates don't deny their own racialism - heck, even the party does not. Thus I tend to think posts like this do not forward the constructivity of this discussion; instead, it just makes sure we get even more BNP morons (i.e. Alarik Martens) with their bizarre view of the world ranting about how cool it actually is to hate the blacks.

Only in Britain!


One of the most frequent BNP arguments is actually that they aren't a racist party, they're just anti-immigration and "britain first". Pointing out that their leaders are holocaust denying white supremacists is always a good use of time. it won't convince the BNP members, but it might stop people joining.
Cataduanes
QUOTE (Lamuella @ Oct 22 2009, 05:08 PM) *
One of the most frequent BNP arguments is actually that they aren't a racist party, they're just anti-immigration and "britain first". Pointing out that their leaders are holocaust denying white supremacists is always a good use of time. it won't convince the BNP members, but it might stop people joining.


yes very true, Mr Griffin has well publicized views on the Holocaust

QUOTE (Nick Griffin)
I am well aware that the orthodox opinion is that 6 million Jews were gassed and cremated or turned into lampshades. Orthodox opinion also once held that the earth is flat… I have reached the conclusion that the ‘extermination’ tale is a mixture of Allied wartime propaganda, extremely profitable lie, and latter-day witch-hysteria.


and i saw you lurking Alarik we are all waiting for your rebuttal biggrin.gif
Squiggers
To be honest, you can't really deny these idiots the rope to hang themselves, particularly as i'll find great amusement in it. Plus, can you really deny them the airtime when we televise the [martyrdom video] rantings of the extremists in the UK? They're hardly better than ol' Griffin and his clowns.

That said, this is part of the reason why i'm also a bit worried about electoral reform - we make it a "fairer" system with more proportional representation, rather than the current First Past the Post system, these idiots might start being able to get a voice - and a say in how things run.
Foggers
BBC iplayer is only availbale to people in Britain.

What if Mr Griffin get's on TV and jumps up, points at the camera and says "zomg lol! we fooled you! hah!"
Squiggers
QUOTE (Foggers @ Oct 22 2009, 06:35 PM) *
What if Mr Griffin get's on TV and jumps up, points at the camera and says "zomg lol! we fooled you! hah!"


That they're a real, viable alertantive to our current major 3 parties?

Badoom-tish.
Kenadian_2006
QUOTE (Foggers @ Oct 22 2009, 01:35 PM) *
BBC iplayer is only availbale to people in Britain.

What if Mr Griffin get's on TV and jumps up, points at the camera and says "zomg lol! we fooled you! hah!"


Oh? It's UK only? That sucks, I want to see this.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.