[Deputy Dangle]

Ok, the way I see it, both of these players deserve a superbowl ring. Favre is old coming back for another year to give his 8-8 team another shot at the superbowl, he breaks all kinds of records and all the hype is around him. Strahan is also old coming back for another (unexpected) year, but he has never had a superbowl win, whereas favre can just leave saying "I was a superbowl champ", and Strahan cannot.

Thoughts? Opinions? Polls? ZOMG I'm bored.

[thewsamity]

David Harris, oh wait...I'd go with my man Brett.

[Creation]

Voted for Strahan.

This post has been edited by Empress van Wain: 19 January 2008 - 05:28 PM

[theArrowheadian]

if this is strahans last season then well he does b/c Farve is coming back, but still voted farve

[MaGneT]

Strahan. I'm a Giants fan, but Favre is my favorite all-time player.

Favre has won before, and Strahan has really kept the Giants defensive front strong all these years. The Packers can get another shot next year.

[Opethian]

Don't like NY teams; voted Favre.

[sparta]

brett favre. i might be a packers fan but i voted him because he might be coming back next year. but the year the packers are having, and how brett favre has been doing this season, you can't really say he doesen't deserve it. This may be Micheal Strahan's last season but i don't think he deserves because of what he did in the beggining of the season. he diddn't show up for practice or training camp, he would never make up his mind about retiring during the off-season where the big blue needed a desision from him quick. im not saying he isen't good or hes a bad guy but bret favre has been playing with heart and soul every game this season. also Micheal Strahan diddn't really do all the work for the big blue, osi umanyura helped out A LOT on defence.

while for bret favre since hes the QB has to lead the team while being 38 years old and STARTING EVERY GAME. (over 250 consecitive games may i add ) That is just plain heart and soul right there. Think about it, a QB, especcily a 38 year old QB gets sacked hard almost every game and not get injured for over 250 games while Micheal Strahan is trained to hit and sack QB like they were dumpsters.

even if i was a giants fan i would still say brett favre because of what he did for this team especcily his whole carrer...

[sparta]

Opethian, on Jan 20 2008, 06:39 AM, said:

Don't like NY teams; voted Favre.

im wierd. my favorite teams are...

baseball: New York Yankees
Basketball: LA Lakers
FootBall: Green Bay Packers
hockey: New York Rangers

yea im wierd, but i love it

[Opethian]

sparta, on Jan 20 2008, 06:47 AM, said:

im wierd. my favorite teams are...

baseball: New York Yankees
Basketball: LA Lakers
FootBall: Green Bay Packers
hockey: New York Rangers

yea im wierd, but i love it

I hate all of those teams except the Packers.

Here we go, Steelers, Penguins (and to a lesser degree) Pirates!

[sparta]

Opethian, on Jan 20 2008, 06:57 AM, said:

I hate all of those teams except the Packers.

Here we go, Steelers, Penguins (and to a lesser degree) Pirates!

sorry about the steelers .

pirates? lol dude how do you feel about that? except the pirates have awsome jerseys

[Opethian]

sparta, on Jan 20 2008, 07:05 AM, said:

sorry about the steelers .

pirates? lol dude how do you feel about that? except the pirates have awsome jerseys

They can't all be winners. Gotta stay loyal.

[pd73bassman]

I voted for Strahan only because he doesn't have a ring, but I want the Packers to win.