Jump to content






Photo
- - - - -

Who would win?

Posted by Gopherbashi , 12 February 2012 · 159 views

Poll: Who would win?

Who would win?

You cannot see the results of the poll until you have voted. Please login and cast your vote to see the results of this poll.
Vote Guests cannot vote

33 {82} (+0) Legacy : 12.54 --> 12.55 (+0.01)
34 {82} (+0) The Foreign Division : 12.49 --> 12.50 (+0.01)


I always love it when two alliances are so close to each other statistically - not only in terms of score, but also in terms of nations. These two are virtually tied in terms average NS, but who would come out on top in a one-on-one fight to the death? No allies, no peace treaties, just a battle of wits and nukes.

Let me know what you think.




Photo
Jacapo Saladin
Feb 12 2012 07:55 PM
depends on how many legacy nations surrender and go neutral.
Probably TFD. They were well organized and had a good system of command, one of the more underrated alliances on blue. At one point. Not sure now.
Photo
Emperor Whimsical
Feb 12 2012 09:04 PM
TFD.
Photo
New Carnoly
Feb 12 2012 09:14 PM
i think TFD has 4 active nations. Legacy would whoop them
When was the last time two major alliances actually had a 1 vs 1 war? Would be pretty cool to see more of it happen.

As for this poll I dont know enough about either partys memberbases to make a real vote. Apart from regular factors you would think of like Warchests, Active members, no fear of pixel loss etc I think the real thing that plays a part is who runs to peace mode more signifigently.

The AA that has the most members run to peace mode would imedietly set themselves up for a possible defeat. Quicker rebuild post war and possible retain more NS at the end but the nations left to fight in war mode against reduced odds would be militarilly defeated for sure.
Photo
Zoomzoomzoom
Feb 12 2012 09:32 PM

When was the last time two major alliances actually had a 1 vs 1 war?


Probably PC/Rok in bipolar, but the stats weren't anything as freakishly similar as TFD/Legacy right now.

When was the last time two major alliances actually had a 1 vs 1 war?

Probably PC/Rok in bipolar, but the stats weren't anything as freakishly similar as TFD/Legacy right now.



Yeah I fought for RoK in that one and it was the closest ive come to a 1 vs 1 situation. In that case PC had a stronger upper teir and RoK had vastly more low teir nations. In the end it gave me the impression that PC had the upper hand as the upper teir strength came though as more valuable then shere numbers in the non-nuclear ranges (RoK outnumbered PC about 3 to 1 in the sub-10K NS range). I guess it depended on your spot in the war, our top teir got chewed up bad but our low teir guys did enjoy some dogpiling odds in many ranges.
MP/SDI/WRC numbers are almost dead on...TFD with 46/36/23, Legacy with 46/35/25.

Think TFD would take it, though; their large nations have a fairly substantial tech advantage.
It all comes down to activity and I don't know which one is more active, each one seems like a bit of a shell (to an outsider).
Whoever makes the first strike wins the war.
Also, you might have more fun trying to pick between Legacy and International. Pretty much the same levels of tech and stuff, but the tiers are slightly out of whack and wave in favor of each other every 15k NS or so.
TFD, a lot a battle hardened vets.

Legacy would just hide in PM.

July 2014

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
202122232425 26
2728293031  

Recent Comments